Proper Relative Humidity
by Mickey Moore
August 20, 2008
|
|
|
*From the Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material,
1999, the Forest Products Laboratory, USDA
Forest Service.
At 70 degrees F a change in relative humidity from 30% to
65% results in an overall EMC change of
nearly 6%. Moisture changes in wood flooring this great will significantly
impact the performance of flooring associated with gaps and cupping. Typically,
a 20% RH change results in an EMC change of
near 3%. This is well within most customer expectations.
|
|
“Proper relative humidity” is a moving target in the wood
flooring industry. Some say best wood flooring performance is obtained when the
RH is controlled between 35-65% RH; others state the RH should be maintained
between 35-55%. Still others say the general recommended range is 30-50% RH.
Other statements use the 35-65% range and warn that RH falling below this range
can result in cupping, gaps, and checks in the flooring. These statements
suggest that flooring does not perform well when humidity levels are outside
these ranges.
But that
is simply not the case. Experience shows you can certainly get very good and
even best performance when humidity levels regularly fall outside these ranges.
For instance low humidity associated with Arizona
or Colorado environments can fall
well below 35% RH regularly. There are many floors that perform to the highest
expectations in these areas. However, flooring subjected to regular seasonal
swings of humidity from 35 to 65% won’t perform on the par of flooring
subjected to the narrower humidity range of 35 to 55% RH.
So who is right?
NOFMA
instructs that the average relative humidity of the area is the target for best
performance of wood flooring in that area. What is good for Miami,
FL is not necessarily good for Memphis,
TN or Denver,
CO. An overall humidity range of 10% more
or less than this target will certainly give very good to best performance. A
wider seasonal range say +/– 15% (30% overall change) or +/- 20% (40% overall
change) can result in noticeable gapping and or cupping. The customer must be
informed of these associated extremes of
expected performance so they can adjust their customer expectations or may even
chose a different product.
NOFMA
promotes the use of wood flooring in all areas of the country and wants
consumers to know that excellent performance of solid wood flooring can be
obtained with most any normal interior seasonal environment. We do not
discriminate against Bar Harbor, ME
and its wide seasonal humidity range of 25 to 60% +. We do caution that wide
plank flooring, 5” and wider, can and likely will exhibit significant gapping
in the winter and may noticeably cup, particularly if not back sealed, in the
summer months when windows are regularly left open. We also do not fault the
Desert Southwest for having consistently low relative humidity between 15 and
30% +. Wood flooring can perform at its
best in this narrow 15% range with little seasonal gapping and no cupping when
properly acclimated to the dry overall environment before installation.
In fact,
the best performance of flooring will occur when relative humidity is static
with little change. A constant relative humidity means there is no expected
expansion or shrinkage after being acclimated to the particular environmental
condition. Install the flooring tight, finish it, and it will remain stable. We
know a static environment is not a realistic expectation. However, flooring
placed in those areas with the least seasonal change will perform better than
flooring placed in areas with wide seasonal differences.
Thus far,
we have been talking about solid wood flooring for the most part; so what about
engineered flooring?
Overall,
properly manufactured engineered flooring by its engineered nature should be
less reactive to relative humidity change than solid wood flooring. That is,
much less related expansion and shrinkage in width due to environmental change
than with solid wood. However, engineered flooring does change more in length
than solid wood, but under normal conditions not enough to be an issue.
Engineered flooring should therefore perform better than solid wood where
environmental conditions have the widest range. In fact many engineered
flooring products are allowed below grade where moisture conditions are
generally higher than on or above grade. Solid wood is not recommended in these
cases.
However,
there are engineered manufacturers that recommend the use of their product only
where the environmental conditions are within a specified relative humidity
range, typically from 30 – 35% to 50 – 65%. You note that these are the same as
with solid wood. When issues arise, particularly those associated with
delamination, claims have been denied because the recorded humidity was above
or below the recommended range. Both NOFMA and the HPVA (Hardwood Plywood
Veneer Association) feel that properly manufactured engineered flooring should
not delaminate under normal environmental conditions associated with any area
in the USA.
This includes the desert southwest with typically low humidity and the gulf
coast and southern coast with typically high relative humidity.
So what is the “Proper Relative Humidity”?
The
related environmental relative humidity of your area is the proper humidity
according to NOFMA. Overall performance will be modified by the conditions. The
wider the range the greater the expected movement and associated performance.
If the
range is wide you can supplement low humidity with humidification. This can
help in those areas with long seasonal heating that tends to over-dry the air,
but a consistent relative humidity above 30 or 35% is likely unattainable.
Also, on those very cold days of low outside RH, the interior heated air will
often be 10 to 15% RH and supplemental humidification set to 30% and above can
create condensation on windows and any area where air leaks occur.
The same
is true for seasonal high relative humidity associated with the warm summer
season. Warm air at high humidity cooled by air conditioning can result in
condensation on surfaces where the temperature drops to or below dew point.
This can result in actual moisture collecting on the related surface. If the
subfloor gets wet the increase in moisture can migrate to the flooring and
result in cupping. In areas where this potential exists remediation actions,
such as keeping the warm moist air away from the cool surface by use of vapor
retarders; actively dehumidifying the at-risk space (such as a crawl space or
basement); or even raising the interior air temperature above the dew point may
prevent the condition. The recommended actions are best done after review by an
engineer familiar with HVAC systems.
Again,
NOFMA believes solid wood flooring and engineered wood flooring should perform
according to realistic customer expectations in any normal interior
environment. A full bath, over or around an indoor pool, directly above a wood
fired heater, are examples of unusual conditions and do not fall in the normal
environmental range. Very low humidity can impact solid wood by causing
shrinkage gaps and some minor checking of the face associated with season
checks already in the wood. It can also impact engineered flooring the same
way, but the shrinkage will be less. The checking can be somewhat more numerous
since the manufacturing process of creating the veneers typically fractures the
wood more than with solid wood. But the checks should be small without wide
splits. High seasonal humidity can create expansion and associated cupping with
both products. But proper acclimation or spacing will minimize seasonal
cupping. The stresses associated with cupping may also result in minor checks
but again properly acclimated and/or spaced flooring will minimize the
condition.
Despite
the ability of properly manufactured wood flooring to perform well in
conditions outside the commonly stated ranges (30-35% RH to 50-65% RH), there
are some manufacturers who recommend using their product only in certain RH
ranges. Typically these recommended ranges are given as a means for the
manufacturer to avoid being liable for claims. NOFMA recommends taking those
manufacturers on their word and avoiding use of their products if the stated
environmental conditions cannot be maintained over time.
Instead
use a properly manufactured wood flooring product that does not make these
restrictive recommendations. Then, properly acclimate it, install it, and enjoy
it.
|