I would bet that in many cases, you could walk into a floor covering store, ask for linoleum and they would show you vinyl. As sheet vinyl started to gain in popularity compared to natural linoleum in the 1960s and 1970s, the term "linoleum" or "lino" continued to be used for all sheet goods, and even a lot of tile products. Even today, sheet vinyl is regularly called linoleum and vinyl composition tile (VCT) is sometimes called linoleum tile. However, these are two totally different products. Linoleum is defined in ASTM F 141 as "a surfacing material comprised of a solidified mixture of linseed oil, pine rosin, fossil or other resins or rosins, or an equivalent oleoresinous binder, ground cork, wood flour, mineral fillers, and pigments, bonded to a fibrous or other suitable backing."
The installer who mentions installing a "subfloor" actually means underlayment. The subfloor in a building is the base structural layer - the very bottom of the flooring system, which could be wood or concrete. This surface, if it's in good shape, could be a good substrate for a resilient floor covering installation. If it's not in good shape, it needs to be covered with an underlayment such as plywood or self leveling underlayment. There are three different terms:
Subfloor: that structural layer intended to provide support for design loadings which may receive resilient floor coverings directly if the surface is appropriate or indirectly via an underlayment if the surface is not suitable.
Underlayment: A material placed under resilient flooring, or other finished flooring, to provide a suitable installation surface Substrate: the underlying support surface upon which the resilient flooring is installed.
To make it simple, you are always installing the floor over a substrate. If the building has a good subfloor, then it can be the substrate. If not, then an underlayment is installed to create a suitable substrate.
Finally, the term "cement" is misused everywhere. It is impossible to walk on a cement floor because cement is a powder that is one of the ingredients in concrete, which is a floor you can walk on. Cement is mixed with water, sand and rocks to make concrete, which is defined as "a strong, hard material made by mixing a cementing material (commonly Portland cement) and a mineral aggregate (as washed sand and gravel or broken rock) with sufficient water to cause the cement to set and bind the entire mass."
It is important to note that linoleum gets installed into wet adhesive, so your adhesive open time is very important, as is the type of adhesive and the trowel you use. Do not use anything other than the recommended adhesive, and make sure the floor is rolled immediately after setting the material into the adhesive. Be sure the trowel notch is appropriate, or even better, buy a new trowel before starting the job. To make sure you have it all right, conduct a bond test.
"The most common cause for failure in any flooring installation is not having proper adhesive transfer," Tim Cole of Forbo explained. "This is one of the main reasons we recommend adhesive bond tests. This gives the installer the opportunity to determine what the working time is with the adhesive as well as the best open time for the job site conditions."
Another difference in Linoleum is maintenance. If it is done correctly, the floor will be beautiful. If not, there can be problems, as explained by Stan Hulin, who wrote about linoleum floor care in the December 2004 issue of ICS Cleaning Specialist Magazine.
"The question is often asked whether there is any difference between maintaining vinyl-type products and linoleum," Hulin said. "Although similar methods of maintenance are used, there is some concern and special care that should be taken when maintaining linoleum floor coverings. Linoleum floors are more sensitive to chemicals and abrasives. Maintenance of linoleum should be strictly in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations. The use of high-pH strippers and cleaners may damage any floor surface, but the effect of strong alkaline cleaners on linoleum is much more apparent. Frequent use of these types of chemicals without rinsing can cause cracking, shrinking and possible discoloration. Aggressive stripping chemicals can leave the surface rough to the touch and very porous because the chemical has etched into the binder of the linoleum. Linoleum floors have a tendency to be susceptible to damage due to over-wetting. Water can attack the oils in unsealed linoleum, or seep into the backing, causing it to rot. If the floor is properly sealed, these problems will be minimal unless the floor is completely saturated and left to stand for long periods of time."
In closing, am I afraid of linoleum? YES! But it's not the product. Linoleum is a fantastic, beautiful, durable, environmentally friendly product. What scares me is that this amazing product that has been around for generations is so misunderstood. Failures abound because of a lack of understanding of installation and floor care. The manufacturers have done a great job of creating training programs but dealers, installers, and floor care technicians need to make it a priority to create the time for training and education. If the right methods are specified and enough time is allowed, then everyone makes money, the job gets done right, and the customer has a beautiful floor that will last a lifetime! It's not difficult, it's just different!
*For more information about ASTM publications, go to www.astm.org or call 610-832-9500.
Thanks to Ric Plies of Compass Concepts for his photographs and his timely assistance, and to Ray Thompson, Tim Cole, and Stan Hulin for their words.