So, how to fix gaps?
There are basically three fixes:
- Fill the gaps with commercial wood filler.
- Take up board or boards and reinstall the boards with no gaps.
- Fill the gaps with the same species of wood slivers.
Filling gaps with wood filler.This is probably the most common type of repair, but it has its limitations. Small gaps lend themselves to application of filler. This is done most often during the sanding process for finishing or refinishing a floor. (Photo 1) The basic instructions are:
- Use a filler color that matches the general color of the unfinished wood. If a different basic color is used and the flooring is ever refinished, the color may interfere with the new color choice. An exception is with wood species that change color with age. Use the filler color that is expected as the wood ages. Domestic cherry and tropical hardwoods fall into this category. Force the filler completely down into the gap to the tongue level of the flooring. (Photo 1)
- When applying filler, fill the gap completely and force the filler to the tongue level. Inadequate filler application results in the filler breaking away and becoming an unsightly, jagged, partially filled gap. This can be worse than the gap itself. (Photo 2) Gaps to 3/64” wide and less are filling candidates. Yes you can fill larger gaps up to 3/32” but at this point the filler itself becomes noticeable and the likely-hood the filler will come out is increased. (Photo 3)
- Also when filling a larger gap, applying the filler and letting it dry then refilling is required, since the initial application will shrink and not completely fill the gap.
- When applying filler, wipe up the excess filler as much as possible. Too much residue can interfere with sanding causing dips and waves as the wheels rollover the bumps.
- Filling the occasional gap in a factory finished floor is also considered acceptable. The filler should match the basic finish color. It should also have a sealer/finish component mixed into the filler or have finish applied after it has set, since normal use will prominently soil any filler that remains unsealed.
Take up boards where gaps are located and replace without gaps.This is generally a less frequent option and is normally used in severe cases after such events as water damage. Flooring subjected to such conditions is also generally loose and noisy and needs refastening. The flooring near a wall line or associated with a doorway is the most often area involved. (Photos 4 and 5)
What are the basic rules for this repair?
- Properly acclimated flooring should be used. That is, the replacement flooring should be at the average moisture content of the surrounding flooring. This requires checking with a moisture meter.
- A good choice for the replacement flooring is the already installed flooring. This should already be acclimated to the site if the moisture issues have been addressed and the flooring has gone through a heating season.
- When the existing flooring is used, nails should be clipped off and the boards measured to place like-size boards in the same run.
- If replacing an area in the middle of the floor, new slightly wider boards may be necessary as the old boards may not fill the space completely and line up with the existing runs. Reinstalling with some gaps may also be necessary if the repair is during the winter. Tight boards without small expansion gaps can result in area cupping later as summer humidity affects the flooring.
- Also light sensitive species will look different from the surrounding older flooring. So it is necessary to set proper customer expectations that the repair will blend over time.
Fill the gaps with same-species slivers.This is becoming a more often used option for repair of gaps. The repair is with the same species so it is not materially different from the existing wood, and a solid properly installed sliver will not break away creating a jagged area during normal seasonal gapping. Larger gaps can also be repaired leaving minimal to no noticeable features, particularly to the casual observer.
- Cut slivers of different widths and about 1/2 the thickness of the flooring. This allows you to choose a sliver that is right for the gap involved. It is not so tall above the flooring, and during installation will not be too fragile. (Photos 6, 7 and 8)
- The typical sliver is cut on an eight-degree angle. (Photo 6) Choose slivers that are a similar color and grain pattern of the boards along the gap. This means if the board is a darker heartwood, don’t cut all sapwood slivers.
- Clean the gap thoroughly and vacuum out any residue. (Photos 9 and 10)
fit the slivers for proper fitting. It may be necessary to cut some of the
bottom point off in order to fit into the different width tapered gaps.
- After fitting, apply wood glue to only one side of the sliver and spread it uniformly. Don’t be overly generous with the glue; a thin coating will be sufficient.
- Position the sliver in the gap and carefully tap it home. You can use a block of wood to tap with, but a larger bearing tends to bend the sliver and may break it. (Photo13)
- Take a sharp utility knife and score the sliver slightly above the level of the floor until the excess is cut away. Too much pressure will also break the sliver and likely pull some of it out of the gap. (Photo 14)
- Finish the operation by scraping the remaining excess to the floor level. Angle the scraper and work from the center to the end. This keeps from pulling parts out of the gap.
- Let all the glue set up before sanding. Also, don’t leave slivers standing in the gap without completing the cutting, as the glue line will be obvious and likely not sand out.
The result should be a floor with minimal gaps and the repair is not noticeable from the standing position. (Photo 15)
All in all, gaps can generally be repaired with attention to detail and proper craftsmanship. Only the most severe general gapped condition with overall loose and noisy flooring requires replacement of the entire floor.
I would like to thank Wayne Lee with Cardinal Hardwood and Tile, Springville, TN for the help with the area repair and slivering.